See here :http://www.trialsjournal.com/content/11/1/43 . An examination of trials of medication for stroke which were completed but never published. This problem, the non-publication of trial data, does not seem to go away. I quote: “Well designed clinical trials should be published because their results can benefit patients, justifying the risk to trial participants from experimental treatments. We […]
Continue Reading →The first false positives….
False positives are one of the many banes of screening programmes. In the US, advertising for people to come to private clinics for expensive CT scans, to screen people for lung cancer is common and, of course, legal. Here in the UK, several private companies advertise their services despite COMARE saying that “we have strongly […]
Continue Reading →Dressings, not drugs
Drugs have quite rightly be subject to a lot of angst from cost-effectiveness viewpoints. The NHS is skint. Generics are cheaper than branded: some branded drugs are not well evidence based, as are some generics, and some doctors are not very good at prescribing cost effectively. I confess to being far more aware of the […]
Continue Reading →Swine flu in the UK – how reliable are the numbers?
So how exactly do we know that there are – as the Health Protection Agency says -around 55,000 new cases of H1N1 “swine” flu each week – especially now that we are no longer swabbing patients before prescribing for it? Extrapolation. The HPA does give a range, between 30,000 and 85,000 cases. There are […]
Continue Reading →Who’d be a guinea pig? : column
To be a “guinea pig” in a clinical trial is not an experience people volunteer for lightly. We need only think of the dramatic side-effects of the so-called Elephant Man drug trial at Northwick Park in 2006 to be reminded that volunteers can end up worse off. In that case, there was financial reward for […]
Continue Reading →The increasing advice about swine flu
To have a baby or not? The National Childbirth Trust, a hardworking parenting charity, have been criticised for offering advice (now withdrawn) that women may wish to delay pregnancy until the swine flu pandemic is over. Various other agencies, including the Royal College of General Practitioners and the Department of Health, were quick to respond by saying […]
Continue Reading →Affording the professions
The Fair Access to the Professions report is just out. The bottom line is that there are not many students studying medicine or law from lower social classes. According to the British Medical Association, just 4 per cent of medical students are from lower social classes. I for one am not convinced that it therefore all […]
Continue Reading →High and dry: column
What do you do for a living? I confess that, when asked this question, I have lied many times. At parties, at gyms and at dinners, I’ve been reluctant to talk about being a doctor, often for the sake of whoever I’m with, as I invariably start moaning about NHS politics. The question of whether […]
Continue Reading →All at sea: column
This column likes evidence-based medicine. It is impossible to defend anything else: to pretend there is no need for evidence – or to ignore it – means ignoring the duty to ensure patients get the best possible care. It would be nice to think that medical research has now got its act together, after many […]
Continue Reading →Health and holiday housekeeping
I’m taking a couple of weeks off the blog to hide from the heat, the lack of which I usually complain about. In the meantime, two thought-provoking treats: an excellent article on cancer screening – It is not wrong to say no – from Dr Iona Heath, who is the new president of the Royal College of […]
Continue Reading →